In Year 12, two years ago now, I wrote a story for my teacher on crime fiction. To this day, that unit remains in my memory as the most beloved of all my subjects. Amazing books, amazing genre, amazing teacher. I have never had more fun. Anyway, he had asked us to each write a crime story based upon one quote by TS Eliot: "Dare I disturb the universe?" This was mine.
The first time Leah Watson attempted to kill Sylvester Holmes was after Terry’s party. She sat in the driver’s seat sideways, back against the door, and watched him. His head was thrown back over the shoulder of the seat, cropped blonde hair gleaming in the streetlight. His mouth hung open, and he snored. Not gently, either.
Leah wondered to herself if the car would still smell of vomit in the morning. It wasn’t like she could air it out, what with this being that sort of neighbourhood. Sylvester emitted a small groan, his arm flopping into his lap. Leah winced at the splat sort of sound it made, and fumbled for the doorhandle.
It was utterly, absolutely typical of the bastard. Always making her do the dirty work. They were meant to be partners. She researched his poisons, his cause-of-death, hung around after him making reports while he coughed up murderers like bullets from a machine gun, and at the end of the day she had to clean up his vomit and bring him hangover tablets, too.
As she opened the car door, the hot humid air hit her like a brick wall. Leah hesitated, glanced at the flashing air-con sign, and then at Sylvester. He snored helpfully.
Hatred welled. Leah only paused for a moment. Then she leaned over, turned the air conditioning off, rolled up the windows, and slid out. The car doors locked. The sound was almost like a gun-shot in the hot, still air. She exhaled heavily, stared at the sleeping blonde in the passenger seat, and then turned and walked up the hill to her house.
But it was only half an hour later when he stumbled in after her, demanding his keys, rubbing his eyes blearily and growling at her for not waking him up. Leah could only mumble “sorry”, unspeakably relieved that he hadn’t slept through the night.
She tried to forget that little voice in the corner of her mind that had screamed in rage when he’d walked through the door.
The second time Leah tried to kill Sylvester was during a follow-that-car routine. She swerved through the rough wilderness outside a little town in the middle of nowhere, trying to keep an eye on the silver car ahead.
Sylvester hung on tightly to the handle above the window and yelled at her above the sound of cracking branches and flying dirt. “I thought there was something funny about him the second I saw him at the funeral. He kept avoiding questions about his wife’s death – I know it’s not a topic any mourner would like to talk about, but the way he did it seemed so strange. Like he was on the spot, you know. And then that photo at the cafĂ© ... well, it was obvious.”
“Yeah,” agreed Leah, who hadn’t seen it coming at all, and thought that the widower’s grief was the most unfeigned she’d ever seen. Pretentious bastard, Holmes.
“Watch it!” Sylvester shouted as they swerved too close to a tree trunk. The silver car flashed out of sight up ahead. “We’re losing him! Drive faster!”
Leah pressed down on the accelerator, gritting her teeth, and fixed her eyes unblinkingly out the windshield. The trees blurred past, not enough time for her to move, and barely enough room to manoeuvre. The silver car appeared again, closer than before and getting steadily closer. Sylvester pressed as far back as he could into the seat and shouted.
“Slow down, slow down! You’re going to kill us!”
The “plan” flashed across her mind in a split second. Catch the criminal. Kill Sylvester. Would she still be able to claim the insurance if she crashed the car? Going too fast – on his orders, too – no one could say it was anything more than a tragic accident.
She floored the pedal.
And both cars burst onto a gravel road. No, not road. Driveway.
There was a brief moment of sound. Leah was aware that she was screaming, and that beside her Sylvester screamed too. The car fishtailed.
Leah slammed on the brakes and hauled on the steering wheel, ignoring Sylvester’s screeched “Don’t break and swerve don’t break and swerve don’t break and swerve!”
For a moment, she wasn’t aware of much besides the fact that the view out the windshield was bouncing around an awful lot and that the car wasn’t slowing down fast enough and that she had burrowed so far back into her seat that her shoulder blades must be sticking out the other side –
The car power-slid along the gravel with a horrible squealing sound to block the width of the road ... and stopped. For a moment, they both sat frozen, breathing heavily, trembling.
Then Sylvester twisted around. “Where did he go?” he demanded in a shaky voice.
Leah stared into the rear-view mirror and felt a sickening heavy weight at the base of her stomach. Sylvester was very quiet besides her. They both stared in different directions at the silver car wrapped around the tree.
Finally, Sylvester pulled a phone out from his coat pocket and began dialling. Leah said nothing as he spoke quietly, feeling a horrifyingly disappointed sensation.
Killed the criminal. Not Sylvester.
The third time, Leah Watson crept into his house with his spare key, stood at the foot of his bed, and watched him sleep. She barely breathed, anxious for him not to wake up.
He lay with his arm flung over the edge of the bed, and his head off the side of the pillow. On the bedside table was a glass of lemonade that she knew he drank when he woke every night at 3 in the morning without fail, from yet another bad dream. In the kitchen, she was sure, was a serrated knife.
She could go down now, grab it and slit his throat. Or she could get the bottle of dissolvable sleeping pills from the bathroom cabinet. It would be dark, he never turned on the light – even if he drank and recognised a strange taste, it would be too late. Then again, if she didn’t want to wait, the pillow was right there. It would be so easy to smother him – sit on his hips with her knees pinning his arms down and wait until he stopped struggling.
Three ways. She should have thought this out better. But then, she’d never really thought she would actually go through with premeditated murder.
Quietly, she padded out of the room and into the tiled bathroom, sliding open the cabinet mirror as slowly as possible. The sleeping pills were right there. Too easy. She slipped back into the bedroom and unscrewed the cap.
One, two, three, four, five ... she watched them fizz in the glass of lemonade and wondered if she should add another couple just to make sure. Was it pushing it? Even half-asleep, Sylvester would recognise an off taste. She held the glass uncertainly and glanced towards him.
Eyes open, he gazed back.